Nestly icon

AI Future Copilot

DashboardStudioLabLibraryBlogAboutGet Started
Should You Withdraw More Before RMDs Begin?
RETIREMENT STRATEGY

Should You Withdraw More Before RMDs Begin?

5 min read • Published about 2 months ago

Waiting to touch your traditional retirement accounts can feel logical. But the years before RMDs begin may be an opportunity to choose when you pay taxes.

N
Nestly Editorial Team
Nestly Team
#retirement-withdrawals
#rmds
#roth-conversions
#retirement-taxes

You retire at 65 with $2 million:

  • $1.4M in a Traditional 401(k) and IRA
  • $250K in Roth accounts
  • $350K in taxable investments
  • $80K in annual spending
  • Social Security starting at 70

You don't need much from the Traditional account yet.

Your taxable savings can cover much of your early retirement spending.

So the obvious strategy seems simple:

Leave the Traditional account alone until you have to touch it.

But those years before required minimum distributions begin can create another decision.

Should you deliberately take money out earlier, even when you don't need it for spending?

Path 1: Take Only What You Need

This is the intuitive path.

Use taxable savings first and take relatively little from the Traditional account.

That can mean lower taxable retirement-account income in the early years.

Meanwhile, the Traditional balance remains invested and continues growing tax-deferred.

The trade-off comes later.

A larger Traditional balance when RMDs begin can mean larger required withdrawals and potentially more taxable income.

The logic is reasonable:

Why pay tax before I have to?

And depending on your future tax situation, waiting may be perfectly sensible.

But waiting is still a choice.

Path 2: Withdraw More Earlier

Now imagine intentionally taking more from the Traditional account before RMDs begin.

Maybe you need only $20,000 from it this year.

Instead, you withdraw $50,000 or $70,000, depending on your tax situation.

The extra money doesn't have to be spent.

After taxes, it could potentially be reinvested in a taxable account.

This path creates more taxable income today but leaves less money inside the Traditional account for later.

The question becomes:

Could paying some tax earlier reduce a larger tax burden later?

Possibly.

But only if your tax situation today is more favorable than the one you eventually face.

Path 3: Convert Instead of Spend

There is another option.

Instead of withdrawing extra money and moving the after-tax amount into brokerage:

Traditional IRA → Roth IRA

You generally recognize taxable income on the conversion today.

But the converted money remains invested inside a retirement account.

That changes the future account mix:

  • Traditional balance decreases
  • Roth balance increases
  • Future RMD exposure may decrease
  • More money may be available for qualified tax-free Roth withdrawals later

That does not automatically make conversion better.

It simply moves part of the tax decision from the future into the present.

Your personalized projection

See what your retirement could look like.

Get an instant estimate of your portfolio at retirement, sustainable monthly income, retirement timeline, and readiness score.

Describe your future.

Tell Nestly about your finances, goals, or future plans in plain English.

Quick scenarios
Retire early
Career break
Market crash
Inflation spike
Healthcare costs
College planning
Second home
Reduce hours

Three Different Trade-Offs

Only What You NeedWithdraw EarlierConvert Earlier
Taxes todayLowerHigherHigher
Traditional balance laterHigherLowerLower
Future RMD exposureHigherLowerLower
Roth balanceSimilarSimilarHigher
Later tax flexibilityLowerMediumHigher
Lifetime taxesDependsDependsDepends

The most important row is the last one.

Lifetime taxes depend on the actual plan.

Why the Traditional Balance Matters

The decision isn't only about this year's tax bill.

Leaving more money inside a Traditional account can create a larger balance when required distributions begin.

Why today's decision can affect taxes later
More stays in Traditional accounts
Traditional balance may grow larger
Future required distributions may be larger
More taxable retirement income may appear later
Actual results depend on investment performance, withdrawals, tax circumstances, and applicable RMD rules.

That doesn't mean a smaller Traditional balance is always better.

It means the timing of taxable income matters.

Taxes Now vs. Taxes Later

Instead of asking:

How do I pay the least tax this year?

A better comparison looks across retirement:

  • Taxes before RMDs
  • Taxes after RMDs
  • Lifetime estimated taxes
  • First projected RMD
  • Traditional balance at RMD age
  • Roth balance
  • Spendable after-tax wealth
  • Plan Success

A strategy that creates more taxable income at 67 could potentially reduce taxable income later.

Or it could simply cause you to pay taxes sooner without enough benefit.

That's why there isn't a universal rule.

When Earlier Withdrawals May Not Help

The result can change based on:

  • Current versus future tax rates
  • Social Security
  • Other retirement income
  • Filing status
  • State taxes
  • Medicare-related income thresholds
  • Charitable giving
  • Investment growth
  • Legacy goals

Even if withdrawing or converting earlier makes sense in principle, the amount matters.

Creating too much taxable income in one year can change the outcome.

The Real Decision

Waiting until RMDs begin may be completely reasonable.

So might deliberately withdrawing earlier.

So might converting part of the Traditional balance to Roth.

The important question isn't simply:

When am I required to take the money out?

It's:

When does paying tax give my retirement plan the most flexibility?

The years before RMDs begin may give you more control over that decision than you'll have later.

Before you leave
Open Lab and test the idea with your plan.

Start from your current plan, change one assumption from the article, and save the version only if it is worth comparing later.

Try as guest
Login only when saving
Open Nestly Lab 2

How we make these. Articles are produced by the Nestly Editorial Team. We use AI for formatting and proofreading, and to create article images. Every Read & Try scenario runs on the Nestly Lab What-If Engine, powered by Nestly Horizon, our proprietary projection and calculator engine, so you can test it with your own numbers.

Related Articles
Which Account Should You Spend From First in Retirement?
RETIREMENT STRATEGY

Which Account Should You Spend From First in Retirement?

9 min read · about 2 months ago

You need $75,000 this year. See how pulling it from taxable, Traditional, or a mix of accounts can change taxes, future RMDs, Roth savings, and the years ahead.

NE
Nestly Editorial Team
Your Best Roth Conversion Years May Be Right After You Retire
Read & Try
TAXES & WITHDRAWALS

Your Best Roth Conversion Years May Be Right After You Retire

5 min read · about 1 month ago

The years after your paycheck stops—but before Social Security and RMDs fully kick in—can create a valuable window for Roth conversions.

NE
Nestly Editorial Team
When Should You Actually Spend Your Roth Money?
RETIREMENT INCOME

When Should You Actually Spend Your Roth Money?

4 min read · about 2 months ago

Roth money can be one of your most flexible retirement accounts. The question is not just whether you can spend it, but when using it may actually help.

NE
Nestly Editorial Team