Nestly icon

AI Future Copilot

DashboardStudioLabLibraryBlogAboutGet Started
Your First RMD: Deadlines, Multiple Accounts, and Common Mistakes
RETIREMENT PLANNING

Your First RMD: Deadlines, Multiple Accounts, and Common Mistakes

11 min read • Published 3 months ago • Updated Aug 10, 2026

Learn what happens when Required Minimum Distributions begin, how the first-year deadline works, how multiple IRAs and 401(k)s are handled, and what to avoid before your first RMD.

N
Nestly Editorial Team
Nestly Team
#RMD
#required minimum distributions
#retirement taxes
#traditional IRA
#401k
#retirement income
#retirement planning

Understanding what an RMD is is only the first step.

The next challenge is figuring out how the rules actually work once Required Minimum Distributions begin.

Your first RMD can have a different deadline from later years.

Multiple IRAs may be handled differently from multiple 401(k)s.

And you may still have choices about what to do with the money after it leaves the retirement account.

This article walks through those rules with simple examples.


What Happens With Your First RMD?

Your first RMD can be slightly confusing because the deadline works differently from later years.

For many retirees, the first RMD is generally due by April 1 of the year after the year you reach your applicable RMD age.

After that, future RMDs are generally due by December 31 each year.

That creates an important choice.

You can take the first RMD during the year you reach RMD age.

Or you may be able to delay it until the following April.

The catch is that delaying the first RMD can create two RMDs in the same calendar year:

  • Your delayed first RMD
  • Your second year's RMD

That can increase taxable income for that year.


A Simple Example

Suppose Robert reaches his applicable RMD age in 2035.

His first RMD is approximately:

$45,000

He could take it during 2035.

Or he may be able to wait until April 1, 2036.

Now suppose his second RMD is:

$47,000

If he delays the first distribution, he could potentially have:

$45,000 + $47,000 = $92,000

of RMDs during 2036.

That does not automatically mean delaying the first RMD is wrong.

It means the timing deserves attention.


Why Two RMDs in One Year Can Matter

An RMD from a traditional retirement account is generally taxable income, except for any applicable non-taxable basis or other exceptions.

So taking two distributions in one calendar year can mean more taxable income during that year.

That may interact with:

  • Social Security
  • Pension income
  • Investment income
  • Other retirement withdrawals
  • Medicare-related income calculations
  • Your marginal tax rate

You do not need to become a tax expert before taking your first RMD.

But you should understand the timing before automatically delaying it.


What If You Have More Than One IRA?

Many retirees have several traditional IRAs.

For example:

  • Traditional IRA #1
  • Traditional IRA #2
  • Rollover IRA

You generally calculate the RMD for each IRA separately.

But in many cases, you may be able to combine the IRA RMD amounts and withdraw the total from one or more of your IRAs.

Example

AccountCalculated RMD
Traditional IRA #1$12,000
Traditional IRA #2$8,000
Rollover IRA$10,000
Total IRA RMD$30,000

You may be able to satisfy the full $30,000 requirement from one IRA.

Or you could divide it across several IRAs.

The key point is that the total IRA requirement still needs to be satisfied.


What If You Have Multiple 401(k)s?

Employer retirement plans can work differently.

Suppose you have:

  • An old 401(k) from Employer A
  • Another old 401(k) from Employer B
  • A current employer 401(k)

Do not assume those RMDs can automatically be combined the same way IRA RMDs sometimes can.

Each employer plan may have its own RMD requirement and distribution process.

That may mean taking separate distributions from different plans.


Should You Consolidate Old 401(k)s?

Some retirees simplify their accounts before RMDs begin.

Fewer accounts can make it easier to:

  • Track balances
  • Estimate withdrawals
  • Manage beneficiaries
  • Coordinate investments
  • Monitor RMD deadlines

But consolidation is not automatically better.

Rolling an old 401(k) into an IRA or another employer plan can affect:

  • Investment choices
  • Fees
  • Withdrawal rules
  • Creditor protections
  • Access to institutional funds
  • Early-withdrawal strategies
  • Plan-specific features

Do not consolidate accounts only because the RMD paperwork looks easier.

Look at the entire retirement plan.


What Happens If You Miss an RMD?

Missing a required distribution can create an excise tax on the amount that should have been withdrawn.

Rules and available relief can change.

The practical lesson is simple:

Do not wait until December to discover whether you have an RMD.

Before your first required distribution, know:

  • Which accounts are affected
  • Your required amount
  • Your deadline
  • Which account will fund the withdrawal
  • Whether taxes will be withheld
  • Whether automatic distributions are available

Does an RMD Have to Be Taken in Cash?

Not always.

Depending on your custodian and account, you may sometimes be able to distribute investments directly from the retirement account into a taxable brokerage account.

This is often called an in-kind distribution.

For example, instead of selling shares inside your IRA and withdrawing cash, you may be able to transfer shares with the required value into a taxable account.

The fair value of the transferred assets generally counts toward the distribution amount.

But this does not make the distribution tax-free.

The RMD is still a distribution from the tax-deferred account.

The difference is simply that you may not have to sell the investment first.


Can You Reinvest an RMD?

Yes, after the required distribution has left the retirement account.

Suppose Robert's RMD is:

$50,000

But he only needs:

$30,000

for spending.

That leaves:

$20,000

Robert may choose to save or invest that money in a taxable brokerage account.

So an RMD does not mean:

"You must spend this money."

It means:

"This amount must leave the tax-deferred retirement account."

What you do with the money afterward is a separate decision.


Can You Put an RMD Into a Roth IRA?

You generally cannot directly roll an RMD into another retirement account.

The required distribution must first be satisfied.

That becomes important when Roth conversions enter the conversation.

You cannot simply take the amount you were already required to distribute and call it a Roth conversion instead.

The RMD and a Roth conversion are separate transactions.

We will cover that distinction later in this series.


Your personalized projection

See what your retirement could look like.

Get an instant estimate of your portfolio at retirement, sustainable monthly income, retirement timeline, and readiness score.

Describe your future.

Tell Nestly about your finances, goals, or future plans in plain English.

Quick scenarios
Retire early
Career break
Market crash
Inflation spike
Healthcare costs
College planning
Second home
Reduce hours

Why RMDs Can Become Larger Over Time

Your annual RMD depends mainly on:

  1. Your prior year-end retirement-account balance
  2. The applicable IRS life-expectancy factor

As you get older, the IRS distribution factor generally becomes smaller.

That means the percentage required to come out of the account generally rises.

At the same time, the remaining retirement account may continue growing.

Those two forces can produce larger RMDs later in retirement.


Robert at Different Account Balances

Using age 75 as a simple illustration:

Traditional Retirement BalanceApproximate RMD
$500,000$20,325
$1,000,000$40,650
$1,500,000$60,976
$2,000,000$81,301

Someone with a $500,000 traditional balance may face a very different required withdrawal than someone with $2 million.

That is why account size matters.

It is also why looking ahead before RMDs begin can be useful.


What If You Do Not Need the RMD?

This happens frequently.

Imagine Robert's normal annual spending is already covered by:

  • Social Security
  • Pension income
  • Taxable savings
  • Other household income

Then an $80,000 RMD could create income he did not actually need for spending.

He still receives the money.

But it may create additional taxable income.

That is where RMDs begin turning from a distribution rule into a retirement tax-planning issue.


Common RMD Mistakes

Mistake 1: Thinking RMD Means You Must Spend the Money

You generally need to withdraw it.

You do not need to spend all of it.


Mistake 2: Forgetting the First-Year Deadline

Delaying your first RMD may cause two distributions to occur in the next calendar year.

Know the timing before deciding.


Mistake 3: Treating Every Retirement Account the Same

Traditional IRAs, 401(k)s, other employer plans, and Roth accounts can have different rules.


Mistake 4: Assuming an Extra Withdrawal Counts Toward Next Year

Generally, it does not.

Each year's RMD is calculated separately.


Mistake 5: Ignoring Taxes

Traditional-account RMDs are generally taxable income except for any applicable non-taxable basis or other exceptions.


Mistake 6: Waiting Until RMD Age to Start Thinking About RMDs

You may have more planning flexibility years before RMDs begin.

Understanding your projected future distributions earlier gives you more time to compare options.


Your First-RMD Checklist

Before RMDs begin, make sure you know:

  • Your applicable RMD starting age
  • Which retirement accounts are affected
  • Your prior December 31 balances
  • Your estimated first RMD
  • Your first-year deadline
  • Your later annual deadline
  • Which accounts will fund the distributions
  • Whether you actually need the money for spending
  • Whether taxes should be withheld
  • How RMDs fit with your Social Security and pension income

A little preparation can make the process much simpler.


Why You Should Estimate RMDs Early

Suppose Robert is only 65 today.

He has:

$1.2 million

in traditional retirement accounts.

His RMDs have not begun.

It might be easy to ignore them.

But his account could continue growing for years.

Waiting until the first required withdrawal arrives may leave him asking:

Could I have planned this differently?

The years before RMDs begin may provide more flexibility over:

  • Withdrawals
  • Taxable income
  • Social Security timing
  • Roth conversions
  • Retirement-account balances

That leads directly into the next article.


The Next Question

Understanding how RMDs work is important.

But the bigger question is:

Why does the size of an RMD matter?

Imagine Robert eventually receives:

  • $45,000 from Social Security
  • $25,000 from a pension
  • $60,000 from an RMD
  • $10,000 of other investment income

Those income sources begin stacking together.

That can change his taxable income in retirement.

And that is where RMD planning becomes tax planning.


Key Takeaways

  • Your first RMD can have a different deadline from later RMDs.
  • Delaying the first distribution may result in two RMDs during one calendar year.
  • Multiple IRAs may sometimes be aggregated for distribution purposes.
  • Multiple 401(k)s can have different RMD requirements.
  • You generally do not have to spend your RMD.
  • An in-kind distribution may sometimes be available.
  • You can reinvest money after taking the required distribution.
  • An RMD cannot simply be treated as a Roth conversion.
  • Larger tax-deferred balances can create larger future required withdrawals.
  • Planning before RMDs begin may give you more options.

Next in the Series

How RMDs Can Affect Your Taxes in Retirement

The next article will show how RMDs can combine with:

  • Social Security
  • Pension income
  • Investment income
  • Other retirement withdrawals

We will compare smaller, moderate, and larger RMDs and show why taxable income can change significantly later in retirement.

After that:

Roth Conversions Before RMDs: When Do They Actually Help?

We will compare:

No conversion

vs.

Moderate annual conversions

vs.

Larger conversions

and look at taxes today, future RMDs, Roth balances, and projected lifetime taxes.


Final Thought

Your first RMD is not something to fear.

It is something to plan for.

Know the amount.

Know the deadline.

Know which account will fund it.

And most importantly, understand how that required income fits into the rest of your retirement.


Further Reading


Important Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not individualized tax, investment, legal, or retirement advice. RMD rules depend on account type, birth year, beneficiary status, employment status, and current tax law. Rules can change. Verify current IRS requirements and consider qualified tax or financial professionals before making retirement-account decisions.

Before you leave
Open Lab and test the idea with your plan.

Start from your current plan, change one assumption from the article, and save the version only if it is worth comparing later.

Try as guest
Login only when saving
Open Nestly Lab 2

How we make these. Articles are produced by the Nestly Editorial Team. We use AI for formatting and proofreading, and to create article images. Every Read & Try scenario runs on the Nestly Lab What-If Engine, powered by Nestly Horizon, our proprietary projection and calculator engine, so you can test it with your own numbers.

Related Articles
Why $2 Million in a 401(k) Isn’t Really $2 Million
Read & Try
RETIREMENT PLANNING

Why $2 Million in a 401(k) Isn’t Really $2 Million

7 min read · 3 months ago

Two retirees can both have $2 million and still have very different amounts available to spend. See why Traditional, Roth, and taxable account balances matter in retirement.

NE
Nestly Editorial Team
What Is an RMD? Required Minimum Distributions Explained
RETIREMENT PLANNING

What Is an RMD? Required Minimum Distributions Explained

6 min read · 3 months ago

Learn what required minimum distributions are, when they start, how they are calculated, and what different retirement account balances could mean for your future withdrawals.

NE
Nestly Editorial Team
How Much Do You Need in Your 401(k) to Retire at 62?
Read & Try
RETIREMENT PLANNING

How Much Do You Need in Your 401(k) to Retire at 62?

10 min read · 4 months ago

See estimated 401(k) balances by spending level, understand what changes the number, and compare retirement strategies with Nestly Lab.

NE
Nestly Editorial Team